What does logic mean as a core value?
Logic as a core value means wanting decisions to follow from sound reasons and reasons from evidence, and trusting a case most when each step clearly follows from the last.
When an argument doesn’t hold together, you feel it straight away. For someone who holds logic as a core value, a conclusion has to earn its place. You’re uneasy when a plan rests on “everyone knows” or when the loudest person carries the room. You can separate how you feel about an idea from whether it makes sense, and you trust a well-reasoned case more than a charismatic one. Contradictions nag at you until they’re resolved.
What does logic look like in practice?
- You ask “what would have to be true for this to work?” before agreeing to a plan.
- You spot the step in someone’s argument where the conclusion stops following.
- You change your mind when someone shows you a better argument, even in the middle of a debate.
- You write out the options and assumptions before a big personal decision.
- You point out when two company policies contradict each other.
When is logic overplayed?
Pure reasoning struggles with people. You can dismiss a concern as emotional and forget that feelings are data too, or win a family argument on points while losing the relationship. Some decisions rest on values or intuition that can’t be fully argued. There’s also the trap of mistaking a tidy argument for the truth. Healthy logic knows its limits. A useful habit, when someone is upset, is to ask what their feeling might be telling you that the argument hasn’t.
Often confused with
Logic vs Intelligence
Intelligence is quick, deep understanding of many kinds. Logic is narrower and stricter: whether each step of an argument actually follows from the last.
Logic vs Rigour
Rigour is being thorough and exact in your work. Logic is about sound reasoning, and you can be meticulous and still draw the wrong conclusion.
Logic vs Truth
Truth is about what’s real. Logic is about whether a conclusion follows, and a perfectly logical argument can rest on a false premise.
Questions to sit with
- Which important decision in your life can’t be fully justified by argument, and how do you feel about that?
- When did you last dismiss a concern as emotional, only for it to turn out right?
- What belief of yours would you find hardest to reason your way out of?
More values in Skill
Competence, intelligence and doing things well.
About the author
Matt Rutherford is a Career and Leadership Coach. The Values Finder is the same exercise he uses with his coaching clients. He also writes Stuff that MattRs, a weekly newsletter with practical ideas to help you think clearer and work better.
Find your own
Is Logic one of your core values?
Choose from 155 values, narrow them down to the few that matter most, and get a personal report to keep. Free, and it takes about 15 minutes.
Find your core values